The stars glint in the open sky as I navigate the coast in the dark. They’re beautiful. They are just the way I remember them. Nothing lasts forever, nothing is static except the stars…and maybe the thing I’m looking for.
I close my eyes and take a deep breath. The same sea smell. That didn’t change either. All these years I’ve been looking for something foundational in my life. Something that wouldn’t change. I’ve looked for it in my parents, my friends, jobs…all these things that people put so much weight in. But they all change. Nothing ever remains static from childhood (heck not even me). But this has endured. This scene. This coast. I imagine that it will endure even long after I have changed again…long after I am gone.
The water brushes up against my feet.
“WOAH! COLD!” That was surprising.
A flash of childhood. I remember that icy surprise from back then. I remember that feeling the last time I was here….when I came to bury it.
I had completely forgotten about that. Even after I had promised myself to never forget. Not even my promises to myself are foundational.
“Ha!” A bitter laugh. No need to beat myself up about it now. Guess circumstances lined themselves up to bring me back here. Something kept my promise to myself despite my forgetting it.
I had come back home for my father’s funeral. We hadn’t spoken since my divorce. He had really liked my ex and resented my not working to keep the relationship together. He could never understand though. I just…
*sigh* Where’s my flashlight?
My uncle (my dad’s younger brother) came up to me during the wake. I figured he wanted to console me (or maybe even be consoled himself). I really wasn’t feeling it.
I wasn’t sad. I wasn’t happy that my dad had died. There was no overwhelming emotion in either direction (well, there was guilt for not feeling sad). Oddly enough, though, he had not come for that…
“Hey, kid, it’s been a while.” He had a warm smile on his face.
“Yeah, I suppose so. How ya been?” This was kinda awkward. I hadn’t talked to this man in years.
“Eh, not so much…” A look of embarrassment crossed his face, “ Well, Denise is pregnant. Ha! That’s exciting!”
My younger cousin, Denise. Wow. The first one of us to be having a kid.
“Wow that’s great! Is she here? How far along is she?” I feigned excitement for my uncle’s sake. Denise and I were never close.
“She’s got a few months left with the little guy inside her. It’ll be a boy. They’re planning on naming him after me. Silly, eh?”
I give a sort of crooked smile, “Understandable, I guess.”
“Ha! Don’t go kissin’ my butt, son: you’ve been absent far too long to make it count for anything!”
Wow…how embarrassing.
“I’m sorry bout that. Too funny to resist saying.” His warm smile came back, “I love ya, ya little turd.”
I give him an ear-to-ear grin. That was his nickname to me. When I was a kid he’d said I earned it for being the only male any of his brothers and sisters had had: the abuse had to fall on somebody. Funny family.
“But no, Denise couldn’t show up. Her and her husband are closing the deal on a house today in Nebraska. Can ya believe it?! Nebraska! She said they wanted the kid to grow up in a wide open space with fresh air. It’s a cute house they got. Guess I can’t fault them for making that choice. I just wish it weren’t so far away…”
I nod in understanding.
“Your dad always loved you.”
Well that came out of nowhere.
“Even though he died pissed at you he loved you very much. He wanted you to know that.”
“So he was still angry with me, huh?” That was slightly disappointing.
“Those last few minutes he probably let it go. Bit superfluous to go into the wide beyond carrying unresolved emotions. Can ya imagine being angry at someone for all eternity? That scares the crap outta me…”
Hadn’t ever thought about that before.
“‘Be careful not to hide your garbage where you hide your treasures’- those were his last words before he slipped away.” My uncle didn’t seem sad or nervous. He seemed to be at ease in relaying all this to me.
“I wish I coulda made him happy. I jus…he wanted something that couldn’t be done.”
“It’s a hard thing he wanted from ya. He always figured you and Lucy were in a pride war with one another. A war of attrition. You’re both strong willed. A strength and a weakness.”
I bow my head. I hadn’t been prepared to hear my ex’s name be mentioned. Man, that hurt.
“You’re father always hoped that you would be the one to swallow your pride first and patch things up. It broke him in half though when you were the one that pushed for the divorce. When you didn’t work for peace, but rather became the arbiter of escalation.”
I was getting pissed at this point, “The old man just didn’t get it.” I didn’t want to get angry here. My uncle picked up the vibe.
“I remember the last time your father was angry with you. It was when you were a kid. Ya did something ta really piss him off. Can’t for the life of me remember what though…”
I laugh, “The ‘Freddy incident’! Wow! I hadn’t thought of that in a LONG time! Yeah he was REALLY pissed about that one!”
My uncle gave me the “remind me” look.
“First year of middle school. I was pretty shy. You remember how I was back then.”
My uncle smiles and nods, “A little turd.”
I laugh, “Exactly! Anyway, Freddy was a year ahead of me. Thought he was God or something. Real punk. Had this thing about picking on me.”
“Now, I’m starting to remember!” My uncle’s forehead wrinkled up as he raised his eyebrows in remembrance.
“Yeah. Anyway, One day I came home with a black eye. My wallet was gone too. Dad asked me what was wrong. Mom was away at some conference or another so I had no shield to block out his intensity. I told him that Freddy punched me in the face and took my wallet. ‘AND?!’ was his response. I had none. He stormed off to the kitchen and didn’t talk to me again until after dinner.”
“Your mother was a saint. He needed her so much.”
“Yeah…anyway, he told me I had to confront Freddy the next day. Said I couldn’t just let that go. Said it didn’t matter if I came home tomorrow with a broken nose, I had to resolve the issue. I had to show that I cared.” This was harder to get through than I had expected. I was surprised to find lots of unresolved emotions.
“Oh, goodness, I remember what happened next.” My uncle said covering his eyes.
“You remember what my dad told you.” I said with a bit of harshness.
“Well, you tell me what happened then.”
“The next day I followed Freddy the entire day. I made sure that he didn’t get an opportunity to sneak up on me. In the lunchroom I remember him glaring at me from across the cafeteria and giving me this really wicked grin.” I had to stop for a second.
“The night before I had gone down to the beach. To that cave on the coast that dad had showed mom and me. It was full of these rocks. I had filled my book bag with them...”
“They closed that beach a while back…” my uncle interrupted , “Some idiot teens were camping in one of the caves along the coast and drowned in the high tide. They were found deep in the cave. Must have gotten stoned back there and just…never thought to get out of there before it filled with water. They have that whole beach cordoned off. ‘safety hazard’.”
“What crap!”
“County couldn’t afford another lawsuit like the one it faced after the drowning…”.
“I remember the bag being heavy” I continued, “The seams of the shoulder straps were exposed and I was terrified the entire day that the whole thing would rip apart. After school let out I walked out slower than usual. I WANTED Freddy to grab me from behind. As I approached the flag pole I heard, ‘Surprise!’ and felt my bag being pulled backward. The plan had worked. He was going to say more, but the velocity of his pull plus the weight of my bag created an enormous push back that he wasn’t prepared for. We were both slung off our feet. Me and my bag wound up landing on top of Freddy’s chest as he hit the ground. I stood up quickly to turn around and start laughing at his face, but when I turned around…” I noticed I was breathing harder.
“You don’t have to…” interjected my uncle.
“Freddy wasn’t moving. One of the teachers saw Freddy grab me and had hurried out to help me, but when she saw this she immediately called for one of the janitors to call an ambulance and then lugged my bag off of Freddy to see if she could do anything. I remember blood coming out of his nose…”
“Freddy turned out ok though” added my uncle. “He had a few broken ribs and a concussion, but he sure straightened his life out after that. I remember keeping an eye out for him after that time. All the way till he went to college.”
“That night I faced dad’s rage.” I continued, “That was the first time I had ever gotten a beating. A REAL beating. I remember he sent me to my room and told me to stay in there until he could figure out some sort of punishment. I felt betrayed.”
My uncle frowned.
“I had only done the best with what he told me to do. And my best just wasn’t good enough. I hated him for that. The next day was Saturday. I got up early to sneak down stairs to see if I could find any clues for what my punishment would be. I saw an empty box marked ‘Goodwill’ sitting on the table. I thought, ‘I’ll be damned if I’m gonna lose all my stuff because I did what he told me to do.’. I went back upstairs, grabbed this small wooden box dad had given me (he told me he built it himself when he was in high school) and filled it with my treasures.”
“What’d ya put in it?”
“…Hell, I can’t even remember. Only…” I twisted my face as I recalled, “…When I came downstairs with the box, I noticed my wallet on top of the TV in the living room. I quickly grabbed it and shoved it into the box and (as quietly as I could) ran out the house.”
“Well…where did you hide the box?”
“I figured that the old man was pretty angry. Angry enough to check any place near the house or maybe even the neighborhood. So I took it to the only place I could think of as being both safe and hidden yet memorable to me. I took it to the cave on the beach.”
“Quite a journey on foot.” My uncle said, twisting his mouth.
“Yeah’, I smiled, “it seemed to have taken forever. But I got it there. Buried it. Promised myself after this whole thing blew over that I would come back there and get my stuff back. I was so angry…”.
“Hard to remember things when you’re angry. Especially when you’re so young.”
“Yeah…I can’t remember the last time I even thought about that box.”
My uncle and I share a moment just staring into each other’s eyes.
“Guess it’s safe to get my treasures now.” I said with a smirk.
My uncle laughed bitterly.
I waited till late at night to come out here. Long after I figured the deputies would bother patrolling this section of the beach. I came here by memory. Can’t believe I had forgotten my own promise to myself. The little boy inside of me was seething.
“I’m sorry” I whisper to myself as I trudge along to the spot of the cave.
And there it was. A stony, white archway surrounding an infinite blackness. I had never seen the cave at night.
“I must be crazy. How the hell am I supposed to find it?!”
“Scardy cat!” my inner child yelled out me.
“…Fine.” Was my only retort as I turned on my flashlight and stepped into the mouth of darkness.
The cave still smelled the same: dank yet fresh. It’s one of those complicated scents that only nature can pull off successfully.
“I didn’t go too far from the entrance to bury it…” I whisper.
I scan the area with my flashlight and notice jutting out of the ground near the left wall of the cave a rock shaped like a shark fin.
“Unbelievable!” I blurt. A flash of memory came over me: I figured the shark fin rock would be a good marker. I remember the little boy finding the rock and yelling, “Perfect!”.
I walk over to the marker and crouch before it. Now what? I didn’t bring a shovel with me.
“You’re not going to need a shovel.” Said a voice behind me.
“Damn!” The jig was up. I’m guessing it’ll be a relatively small fine, “Sorry, officer.” I say as I stand up and turn around.
Laughter. I shine my light into the entrance of the cave and find my uncle standing there, “You didn’t bury it too deeply. It’s just a few rocks that can be moved by hand.”
“How…”
“Get to work, turd!”
I turn around and start tossing rocks aside. After about a foot or so of rocks I notice plastic and a bright yellow nylon rope wrapped around the plastic. I also notice that the hole is being supported by a few wooden buttresses. I grab the rope and pull. After a few tugs I’m able to bring up the plastic-wrapped box. I place it onto the ground next to me.
“I don’t remember doing that.” I say in reference to the plastic and the rope. My uncle hands me a pocket knife to cut the rope and plastic sheet.
“Wanna tell me how you know so much?” I ask not really expecting an answer. He offers none.
After a few minutes I’m able to cut my way through all the layers of plastic.
“Thar she blows” I say out of the corner of my mouth. My uncle chuckles.
I open the box, “Let’s see: my baseball glove! That’s where ya went! Comic books (nice), sunglasses, these CDs would have been nice to have taken to college with me, a few of my favorite t-shirts (guess I had a thing for tie die, eh?), a fossilized tooth (I forgot that I was into paleontology at one point) baseball cards, a video game (yeeeesh! I remember LOVING this game), a couple VHS (‘Land Before Time’…really?) eh…the wallet…”.
I open the wallet up. Inside are an old picture of my parents, a library card, a few quarters…not much.
“Wonder if I had any bills in here?” I say as I open up the pocket, “What the…”
Inside the pocket is a folded piece of paper, “A note?”
I open it up and shine the light on it:
“Dear son,
I couldn’t sleep the night I beat you. I stared at your doorway for hours in utter horror of what I had done. Not just the beating, but what I had convinced you to do. I was so ashamed of myself. I still am in many regards.
I did not instill in you the manliness that I had aspired you to attain: one that was tough, but soft. In my hastiness to see a completed product I left you an open-endedness in dealing with Freddy that nearly killed him and most certainly calloused your heart. When I beat you I thought I would break that. Head it off at the pass. But instead I made it stronger. I enabled you to accept and even promote the escalation of bad things, rather than the restoration of peace and order. I taught you to hang onto your pride and bury it, (Save it like a treasure!), rather than let it go like the trash that it is. I am so sorry for setting you on that course so long ago.
I followed you to the beach that day you buried this box. I made sure you didn’t see me. After you left the cave I went in it to see what you had done with the box. I knew then that you would never trust me ever again while I was still alive, and decided that I only had one real action I could take that would set you right in the future. I went to the local hardware store and got the tools necessary to preserve this box in this cave for a long time. I always hoped though it would not be my death that would bring you back to the box.
I had the highest hopes for your marriage to Lucy. Thought that would set you right. What a fool I am! How could you be a good husband when I never taught you how to be a good man?! Your marriage became subject to the style of escalation that I had taught you to embrace and was destroyed.
I did what I could to make you go back to her, but I knew you wouldn’t trust me. Son, believe me: as angry as I was at you for leaving her, I was more angry at myself. That anger was tethered to that old resentment I had made against myself way back when you were still just a scared boy. I am so sorry.
I am getting ready to leave this earth and we have not spoken since your divorce. I am angry at you, of course. I have treasured that anger against you and myself like it were the most valuable thing in the world. As if it would vindicate me. I realize now that it will not.
Look around you, son. What do you see? A landscape that will far-surpass both our lifetimes. An image of eternity. An image of your soul. I will not carry my treasured garbage into eternity with me. I leave it here where it belongs. I pray that this act frees you. That my love would displace anger from your heart. I love you. Do not confuse your garbage as treasure. Do not hide it in eternity to torture you forever. Recognize what is truly valuable. I love you.
-Dad”
“He came back here year after year to check on this site.” I looked up from the letter into my uncle’s eyes. “To make sure that you would be able to find it. That it would look the exact way you left it so that you could find it on your own.”
I couldn’t help it: I started crying.
“Your father was a hard man. He loved you…it’s just…raising a boy into a man that you hope to be better than yourself is a task that is above mere human strength. That’s what he learned toward the end. That’s what he needed you to know. He needed you to see something that was stronger than his resolve: he needed to show you his weakness. That he messed up. That he needed your forgiveness…”
“I’M SORRY, DAD! O, GOD, I FORGIVE YOU!” I’m losing all control.
“He knew you would. I don’t think he could have died if he didn’t trust in that.”
“How did you know about all this?” I ask, wiping away tears from my face.
“He brought me out here with him a month ago. He showed me the cave. Told me he was dying. Had me help him lift that box out of the hole and unwrap it and help him put that note inside. He was so weak toward the end. So drained. Made me promise him that I would help you get back to this place.” He looked tired, “What are you going to do?”
“Thank you so much. I’ll make sure to be less of a stranger.” I give my uncle a hug as I walk out of the cave. The sun was starting to rise red over the water.
“A new day.”
I pull out my cell phone. I recall the number I wanted to dial. There are a few rings before the phone is picked up.
“Hello?” answers a groggy voice on the other end.
“Hello, Lucy. I’m so sorry for what I’ve done…”
I continue walking down the beach talking, leaving the garbage I had treasured so much behind.